- There something bizarre about AI, a thinking machine, accusing me of making ad hominem attacks on authors of ideas I don't like.
- A machine that is not a person doesn't want you to reference the person behind the ideas being debated. What did you say exactly?
- The subject was the state, Hannah Arendt's claim that deprivation of citizenship, denying the 'right to have rights', is an enabling condition of mass murder, and the historian Timothy Snyder's extension of this idea to wartime countries in which the state had been destroyed and the urge to mass murder given free reign.
- Didn't Arendt come up with the idea that Adolf Eichmann, the Nazi bureaucrat of mass murder, showed us the banality of evil?
- Yes, and here was the problem I was having with these ideas: the strong state is supposed by Snyder to be a restraint on mass murder yet at the same time bureaucracy is an element of the strong state, not the weak.
- And a strong state can more consistently distinguish the rights holder from those deprived of rights.
- Yes. Should I tell you about my crime of ad hominem attack, according to AI?
- Go ahead.
- I raised the question of Synder's wealth, calculated by Google to be 5 million dollars, and of Arendt's love affair with Heidegger, the infamous German philosopher who became a Nazi.
- And weren't these ad hominem attacks?
- I think that both Arendt and Snyder were making idols, putting ideas before understanding: Snyder making an idol of the state, a thing with mysterious powers over human behavior, creating a romance of the state that offered mystical protection against mass murder; Arendt romantically re-associating after the war with her mass murder tainted philosopher teacher.
- Synder you argued had a culpable attachment to the status quo, to the state, to protect his millions, and Arendt had compromised herself by indulging in a blind idealism of love.
- Yes. The bureaucrat of the strong state is not banal, rather is the product of a choice to act in a group acting out the script of national rebirth: the apparent banality is the secure repetition, within a group of similar actors, following upon the dramatic, violent group enactment of weakness and returned strength.
- In other words, an understanding of human nature, such as you just gave of the 'banality of evil,' should guide the creation of the state, what about it is necessary, what not, which kind of state is beneficial, which not, not the state be seen to create the nature of the human being by its granting and withholding rights.
Further Reading: